Book Review: Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch

lockelamoraPublished: 2007 by Gollancz

Where I got it: Excited about the release of Scott Lynch’s Republic of Thieves, the third book in his Gentlemen Bastards series? So are folks at Gollancz, who graciously provided me with a review copy.

‘His name is Locke Lamora, and I wager the Order of Perelandro will find many uses for his, ahhhh, unusual degree of personal initiative.’ With these words, young Locke Lamora is sold, nay, almost given away by the Thiefmaker of Camorr to Father Chains, head of the gang called the Gentlemen Bastards. What the Thiefmaker means by ‘degree of personal initiative’ is that Locke is so obsessed with stealing that he, simply, ‘steals too much’. In Camorr, city rife with corruption, everyone steals, so it takes some special talent to stand out. Locke stands out (but obviously not enough to get caught) by breaking rules. He breaks rules as soon as lands in the hands of the Thiefmaker. Lamora calls himself the ‘secret tax’: he takes  from the rich and violates agreements between Camorr nobility and Camorr underworld right and left.

And yet Locke is not the most interesting character in The Lies. He is not even all that charismatic. But perhaps this is intentional. Were he too colorful, he wouldn’t have survived long as a con man and a thief. It’s the people around him who add real color and character to the story. Jean, with a pair of axes he calls the Wicked Sisters. Bug, a young thief apprentice, who bravely jumps into a pile of ‘brown glop’ to save a con game from being blown by the city watch. Women gladiators who battle jumping sharks (yes, even minor characters occasionally seem more interesting than Locke).

The city of Camorr is loosely based on medieval Venice. At times descriptions of scenery makes it seem like you are in a very well-rendered video game (think Skyrim), and that’s probably the reason it also reminded me of Sigil, the city in Planescape: Torment. It has its unique elements – the Teeth Show, Elderglass, Gentled animals (and world-building is always in the details, so the city is not as generic as it seems at first glance).

I have to be honest and say that The Lies is by no means original. Stories of con tricks and heists are a dime a dozen. People use words like ‘rollicking adventure’ to describe books like this. It is absolutely ridiculous at times. Characters engage in over-the-top witty banter. Improbable heists are schemed and characters narrowly escape certain death. Every chapter ends in cliffhanger (Lynch does this in a very George R. R. Martinesque manner and, surprise, the book has a blurb by Martin himself on the cover!). But there is a reason this sub-genre is alive and well, and that is because such stories are pure and absolute fun. Sometimes you just need a rollicking adventure. Sometimes you need to read about things you would never do in real life (I doubt that conning rich dukes into buying fake brandy is high on most people’s bucket lists). I enjoy the wit, the unlikely dialogue, the seemingly impossible cons. Being a speculative fiction junkie, I also enjoy the supernatural elements and the fantasy world. I give The Lies of Locke Lamora five out of five sharp throwing axes.



  1. This has quickly become my favorite fantasy series. I wasn’t even a huge fantasy fan when I started reading it. But i’m now hooked on fantasy, sword and sorcery, con-man tales, etc. these books are the fantasy version of Ocean’s 11, and man, I can not get enough of it! Have you read any further in the series? do you plan to?

    1. I have read Red Seas Under Red Skies when it first come out, but I’m yet to read the third one. Now that Lynch is back to writing, I’ll get back to these books.

      Have you read Joe Abercrombie? The Blade Itself and its sequels?

  2. I’m reading Republic of Thieves at the moment. Lies was my favorite so far, and though I agree with your criticisms, I loved it too. Red Seas was a little slow for me, but I am really enjoying Republic.

    1. I still need to read the republic. Maybe one week I’ll just sit down and read all three. Or I could wait till the new one, supposedly due out later this year…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s